Dr Mara Singer joins Matt and Jasmine to unpack trust portfolios: why brand credibility rests on distinct human voices and how to govern them.
Shownotes
AI has made polished brand content cheap and everywhere. Buyers have noticed, and they are now deciding which people to believe.
Who this is for: marketing and product leaders at life science tools companies.
Jasmine Gruia-Gray talks with Dr Mara Singer of the University of North Texas and Matt Wilkinson about their new peer-reviewed paper in Administrative Sciences, "Trust Portfolios in Online Brand Communities". They walk through the trust portfolio map, from Tesla's lone maverick to the role-diverse communities at LEGO, Sephora and Stack Overflow. Then they test the idea against life science realities such as closed-door user groups and procurement-led buying decisions.
Key idea: Brand trust rests on a portfolio of distinct human voices, and governing them too tightly breaks that trust at the source.
What you will learn
- Why credible voices are not interchangeable across roles
- How the map of voices against governance places Tesla, LEGO, Sephora and Stack Overflow
- Where most life science tools companies sit on that map today
- How to build influence with procurement and other decision makers beyond the user community
- Why centrally supplied content posted without disclosure erodes trust faster than you expect
- How to orchestrate a smaller set of strategically important voices with helpful guidelines
Chapters
- [00:00] Welcome and introducing Dr Mara Singer
- [01:14] Authenticity across generations
- [03:14] Trust as risk diversification
- [05:16] What a trust portfolio is
- [07:11] Mapping voices against governance
- [11:51] LEGO, Sephora and Stack Overflow
- [12:39] Where life science tools companies sit
- [15:26] Offline communities and user groups
- [16:47] Reaching procurement and decision makers
- [18:44] Three takeaways from the paper
- [21:26] Orchestrating voices without scripting them
- [24:16] Trust broken at the source
- [25:13] Close and where to read the paper
Keywords: trust portfolio, brand trust, life science marketing, employee advocacy, brand community, source credibility, AI generated content, thought leadership, life science tools, user groups, procurement influence, Mara Singer
Watch the full episode, subscribe for new conversations every week and read the open access paper "Trust Portfolios in Online Brand Communities" in Administrative Sciences. Find out more about Strivenn at strivenn.com.
Transcript
In this episode, Jasmine Gruia-Gray is joined by Dr Mara Singer and Matt Wilkinson to discuss their paper on trust portfolios. The conversation moves from Mara's research on authenticity across generations to the two-by-two map of voices against governance, then into how life science tools companies can apply the framework, including user groups, procurement and the risks of over-controlling brand voices.
Introducing Dr Mara Singer
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [00:01]
Hey Matt, we've got a special episode of A Splice of Life Science Marketing today. How are you?
Speaker: Matt Wilkinson [00:07]
I'm good, thank you. How you doing, Jasmine?
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [00:09]
Good, good. Well, let me kick it off and then introduce our guest today. Matt and I first met Mara Singer at Mark Schaefer's Uprising Conference last year, where she presented her research on generational differences. A year later, at the same conference, Matt and I sat in on a fireside chat between Joe Pulizzi and Mark Schaefer, and heard them describe something called a trust portfolio. Matt took the idea to Mara, and the result is a peer-reviewed paper in Administrative Sciences, and I've got a copy of it here: Trust Portfolios in Online Brand Communities. Mara, welcome to A Splice of Life Science Marketing.
Speaker: Mara Singer [00:59]
Thanks for having me. I'm excited to be here and chat with both of you and see you both again.
Authenticity across generations
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [01:02]
We are too. Before we get into the paper itself, can you tell us a little bit about your research on generational differences and what you presented at Uprising?
Speaker: Mara Singer [01:14]
You bet. So my area of research really focuses on digital communication, digital channels, but more specifically looking at trust and authenticity within those channels of communication. And something that really stuck out in a lot of the research I was doing was that each generation builds authenticity and often builds credibility through different factors. And so that was the research that Mark had asked me to come and present to the group, and really looking at the six elements that create authenticity and where each of them go. So that was kind of that research, yeah.
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [01:58]
I think you opened a lot of our eyes to those differences and what authenticity really means to each of those generations.
Speaker: Mara Singer [02:09]
Yeah, the framework that I generally look at is six factors of it. And so it's not just, are they an expert, are they proficient in this area? There are other components to authenticity, and depending upon the generation, which are generally differentiated by technology change, that makes a big difference. And so it's something that the consumers are aware of just internally, but as a result, companies need to be aware of externally so that they know what to do to create authenticity and develop credibility and trust with their consumers.
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [02:48]
Yeah. And I think it definitely applies to the life science industry that Matt and I have spent our careers in.
Speaker: Mara Singer [02:56]
Absolutely. Absolutely. Because this is not something that just shuts off when you're a consumer. It's also something you take into the business world. It's generally subconscious, people are not aware of it, so it follows them everywhere they're at. So it does apply to every different sector.
From personal brands to trust as risk
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [03:14]
Very cool. Matt, you heard Joe and Mark talk about trust the way an investor talks about risk. What shifted for you in that moment?
Speaker: Matt Wilkinson [03:27]
Well, you know, we've been talking about personal branding for a long time and building personal brands. And I've done a lot of work with organisations building, you know, whether it's advocacy from key opinion leaders or from executives, and getting their voices out there and building thought leadership. And I've been doing that for two decades or more. But what I don't think I'd ever really seen it as is this kind of risk diversification.
I think there were two really important things. One, as AI enables more and more content to be created, the value of that content and the trust in brands is changing. So the value of content is diminishing, but also trust in brands is changing. I'm not saying it's different, you know, but how we learn to trust brands, I think, is changing. But one of the other things is that we're seeing in social media and other places that, actually, individuals have greater reach with specific groups than brands do. And so one of the things that Joe's been talking about is, can you strategically position individuals to communicate with the groups that you want to communicate with, and use their voices as part of your brand trust portfolio, rather than just relying on the brand to kind of bark at the world?
And so that was something that Mara and I were talking about. She mentioned this opportunity to submit an abstract to Administrative Sciences, and I said, well, what about this? And that's where this paper started.
What a trust portfolio is
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [05:16]
Well, maybe now's a good time. Maybe you, Mara, can define for everybody what a trust portfolio is and how you looked into it in the paper.
Speaker: Mara Singer [05:29]
Well, sure. Trust portfolio is actually a term that's been around academically since about 2008. We had some people in the sciences who were using it to look at public relations, and the idea that Joe has created is an expansion on that, and it's actually more public facing, which I think is extremely valuable for companies now. But it's looking at the number of voices, and not necessarily the number meaning quantity, but the number of roles of voices, and then also the governance that's over those voices, meaning is the company giving the content to those creators, or is this user-generated content as well?
And so in our paper we're really looking at defining that framework of trust portfolio, and what are the different roles, how are they governed, and then how do those differentiate in trust? And I think, you know, Matt has done a really good job of explaining that in a very clear and easy to understand way as well. So some people have touched on the idea of trust portfolio in that science area, but we've really done kind of the first introduction of that academically from a broader perspective, not just a science PR perspective.
Mapping voices against governance
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [07:11]
Maybe I can pull on that red thread a little bit more. You actually map out the trust portfolio on two axes. Can you describe that a little bit more, and what each of the quadrants that you've labelled lone maverick, managed voice, orchestrated network and emergent community actually mean?
Speaker: Mara Singer [07:34]
Sure, and actually I'll flip that over to Matt and let him explain that to you.
Speaker: Matt Wilkinson [07:38]
Yeah, so along one axis we've got number of voices, and that's pretty easy to understand. Have you got just a single voice? Is it just a single brand, or is it an individual within the brand? You know, if you're really looking at the archetype for that example, it has to be Tesla and Elon Musk. Tesla and Elon Musk, and to an extent SpaceX and Elon Musk, are synonymous. There is no way to separate those brands. And in the paper, we actually go on to show the risk associated with having a single voice, particularly when they say things that can upset people and markets, that then can have a direct impact on share price. And we've seen that.
So you've got the number of voices, but where I think it's really interesting is the level of governance as well: how much oversight and coordination is there of those voices? So, you know, Tesla tends to sit in the bottom left, the lone maverick, because there's very little governance by the brand of the individual involved. It's actually the other way around. If you go to the majority of times where you've got, you know, a few voices, often from the exec team, you've got very strict governance of those voices, and more often than not it is company messaging that is being portrayed by those individuals. So it's almost individuals parroting the brand message.
Then at the bottom right-hand corner, you've got this emergent community, where you have a large number of voices, but you don't have a lot of oversight of those. That's where you might think of a lot of people engaging on social media, having their own personal brands, their own conversations about the brand, without really having a lot of governance. And then top right, you have a very strategically governed large number of voices. So it's going from having an emergent place to actually having a lot of command and control over a lot of people, often with content being fed into them for them to then use in social media.
And the trust portfolio zone that we tend to identify sat a little bit in the middle, a little bit offset to the right-hand side. So there are more voices and a moderate amount of governance, so it's strategic. There are guidelines around the brand and the voice and the sorts of things to talk about, but there's also enough space for the human to be human. And so it's about getting that balance right, so that you're definitely a representative of the brand, but you're also human and engaging and empathetic. So that's kind of the two-by-two.
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [10:49]
Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Sorry, go ahead, Mara.
Speaker: Mara Singer [10:52]
Just going to say, to add on to what Matt was saying, it's that experience that each of those voices brings and the expertise that they bring, the perceived authenticity of them, and then the authority that they have collectively. And so those come from the variety of roles that they have that help to create the stronger trust portfolios as well. So it could be a variety of roles, meaning employees, or maybe somebody who's not an employee but they're an expert in that field, or a customer advocate. Content creators can also be in that mix, meaning paid influencers or maybe unpaid influencers. And then moderators as well. And in the paper we bring in each of these to show what those roles look like and how they can add to or detract from that trust portfolio.
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [11:51]
Yeah. So patterns mean a lot to us as scientists, and certainly in marketing and product management as well. You have LEGO, Sephora and Stack Overflow within that trust portfolio zone. What do they have in common?
Speaker: Matt Wilkinson [12:14]
I mean, that's a great question. A lot of it comes down to really the fact that they're creating ecosystems of voices. There's real input from a brand perspective, but again, they have authoritative voices in places that people are listening.
Life science tools on the map
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [12:39]
Okay. And Matt, if we can continue the thinking into the life sciences and life science tools companies, how do they sit on this map today, and which voice are they usually missing?
Speaker: Matt Wilkinson [12:56]
Well, obviously there's a wide spread of these. Often you see in the startups a lot of lone mavericks. And what I believe tends to happen is that as they grow they bring in, you know, marketing and comms, and they go from being lone mavericks to managed voices. So very rarely do they start actually having many peer-to-peer conversations. When those peer-to-peer conversations actually happen, they're less about having a managed conversation, particularly online.
Often what happens is that you will have a company poster at a trade show and you'll put a scientist out there. You and I have both been there, we've seen this. There's not necessarily a lot of training about the branding and the messaging and the sales process. So there isn't a lot of governance or training, or, you know, the strategy is around what paper do we put out, what poster could we actually put out there at that trade show or that conference. So they either sit in the managed voice or the emergent community. And really there aren't many examples where there are really orchestrated networks.
Because of the way that they've operated, Oxford Nanopore have a very, very lively community. And so I'd argue that they were probably one of the few where there is a real case to be made for them having a trust portfolio. But I'm not involved in that community enough, and we haven't studied them, to really be able to say, well, actually, do they have enough of those voices to really make a case for them having a strong trust portfolio, or is it merely more of a community of scientists helping other scientists? Yes, they've created communities, but have they really strategically thought about who we need to influence to make sure we're getting sales, rather than how do we make sure that scientists are talking about us? And so there is that whole argument around how do we make sure that we have influence with the people that make decisions. And that's the really important thing.
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [15:26]
I think also in the life sciences, because of confidentiality, there may be communities that embody this trust portfolio zone, but they're offline. And, you know, they happen in hotel rooms that are guarded almost from too broad of the information getting out.
Speaker: Matt Wilkinson [15:53]
Yeah, absolutely. I think a good example of those are those strategic user group meetings, where you bring trusted voices in, you bring friendlies in amongst people that you want to influence. I think the challenge with those is that you're still tending to be focusing on the user. I've not seen too many examples where people are reaching out beyond into the rest of the organisation that are making decisions. Now, maybe it is that the scientist has the biggest amount of sway in making a decision. But often I think decisions can be made at far more of a procurement, strategic level. And then how does that operate? How do we make sure that organisations are influencing there as well? So there are some interesting wrinkles in that argument too.
Reaching the people who decide
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [16:47]
Yeah, I think it's a tough one. I mean, by definition, user groups are going to have different levels of users within an organisation, but building procurement into that kind of forum is very difficult. And yet marketers and product managers are always required to connect the dots between those user groups, and between more public communities, and revenue. So what advice do you have for our listeners on how to bridge that gap?
Speaker: Matt Wilkinson [17:28]
Well, I would look at where those people congregate. Let's just take the example of procurement that you just gave. Where are procurement professionals in the life sciences influenced? You need to research that. There are definitely places and ongoing learning that they are influenced by. And how do you then make sure that your company has a voice in those communities? So it's not necessarily about just transplanting somebody from procurement into a user group. It's actually more about going, okay, how do we strategically influence those people? So make sure that the first time procurement hears about us isn't because a scientist said, hey, there's this new company, but actually maybe they're also thinking, hey, they've had some really interesting thoughts about X in the procurement process. So it's just that: as a brand, how do we make sure that we're communicating with all of the influencers that make decisions about purchasing from us?
Three takeaways
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [18:44]
Super. So Mara, what do you think are the three big takeaways from this paper that we haven't talked about yet?
Speaker: Mara Singer [18:55]
Well, for me, the biggest one is that these different voices we're talking about, they're not interchangeable. You can't take the consumer voice and trade it off for an employee voice. So we've got to be very cognisant of whether this credibility is spread across the different voices in a way that resonates with our consumer, because they are not equivalent to each other.
Number two, and jump in, Matt, if you've got anything there, I would say that there is a teeter-totter balance between governance and then visibility of that governance, meaning that you need to disclose if there's paid content, because if you don't and it's found out, then it starts to erode the trust at a much greater rate than you would expect.
And that can be done a couple of different ways. I can give you an example. My husband's company, and I won't name it just to protect the innocent there, have asked him as one employee to be a part of their trust portfolio and to be disseminating content. And they've told him, you can come to this hub that we've built and you can grab whatever social media content you want and post it. But the problem is, okay, they've created this content for him and he'll post it. But what happens when the person in the office next to him does the same thing at about the same time? And then your audience, whoever that might be, whether you're trying to attract more employees who are strong in a particular area, or if you're trying to garner clients, if they see that, then it becomes very evident that this is planted. And if there's no disclosure of that governance, then that can really start to erode that trust.
And I think third for me, what I really appreciated about Matt coming with this is that, especially in a time where AI content is so cheap and easy to get out there in a very polished way, a trust portfolio becomes more important because it is a human voice, and it does garner and develop stronger credibility than AI will ever be able to do. So for me those were the top three. I'm not sure about Matt.
Orchestrating voices without scripting them
Speaker: Matt Wilkinson [21:26]
Yeah, let me build on two things you said then, because they really get me excited. So the first is that human voice piece, which I think is incredibly important. And it has to be human and not the brand. I think that's really important. So it's not just AI voicing, it's overly polished brand messaging.
And I think that then comes to your second point, where you were talking about, you know, if we just give people content and ask them to post it, they can go off and post it all at once, and you could have two people that sit next to each other posting the same post at the same time to the same network. That goes to overly controlling the voice, but not orchestrating the voices. So you've got to be very careful. If you're going to have a real command and control approach and be very, very controlling about the voice, you then have to be very, very controlling about who says what and when, rather than just what you can say. So you either have to be all in on, you know, playing the puppet master to all of your voices and really managing that, which I don't recommend, by the way, because I think that adds a level of overhead and a level of dissociation from the person that's posting it anyway.
I think what we really need to do is to provide really helpful guidelines as to what to post, you know, suggestions, and then really foster maybe fewer voices, but make sure that they're the strategically important ones: one, that enjoy communicating, but two, that have the capacity to build the authority in the communities in which those voices are needed.
Speaker: Mara Singer [23:28]
I completely agree with you on all of that, yeah.
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [23:31]
Yeah, so what I learned from both of you is humans are complex, and we keep figuring out how complex we really are, both from how to build trust, what trust really means, and how to display that authenticity. I think this example from your husband's company really gets to the heart of what not being authentic really means. If there are two, maybe more, people who are amplifying the exact same message, then you've lost that authenticity, and as a result credibility and trust start tumbling down.
Trust broken at the source
Speaker: Matt Wilkinson [24:16]
Yeah, and I think it also goes to the point where, by its very nature, this is called a trust portfolio. We're asking people to trust voices. But if the organisation doesn't trust those voices themselves, and so wants to overly govern them, then the trust is broken right at the source rather than at the edge. And so we have to be really careful that that trust has to span from the centre all the way through to the customer. We can't have an overly broken system where we're just going to dictate everything. Otherwise, it's just one person at the centre that is going to have to be managing every single part of that communication network. And if you're doing this right, that's too many conversations to really manage.
Closing
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [25:13]
Yeah, I think that's a great point, Matt, and maybe we should end on that. Mara, thank you very much for joining us on A Splice of Life Science Marketing. And I would encourage all our readers, again, the publication is in Administrative Sciences and it's called Trust Portfolios in Online Brand Communities: Distributed Human Credibility, Trust Transfer, and Effortless Marketing.
Speaker: Matt Wilkinson [25:43]
And the good news as well is that it is open access, so anybody can go and get a copy.
Speaker: Mara Singer [25:50]
Absolutely. Yeah. Thank you for having me. It's been fun. I really appreciate it.
Speaker: Jasmine Gruia-Gray [25:54]
Thank you.
Speaker: Matt Wilkinson [25:54]
Thank you, Mara.
Q&A
Where do I start mapping our trust portfolio next week?
Block two hours with one colleague from sales or support. List every person who speaks publicly about your brand and tag each by role: employee expert, executive, customer advocate, content creator, moderator or ordinary member. Beside that list, write the five questions buyers ask most often. Draw a line from each question to the role that can credibly answer it. Any question left without a line is a gap, and finding it costs nothing.
We already run an employee advocacy hub. Could it be hurting us?
Check it this week. Pull the last month of posts made through the hub and look for identical wording posted by colleagues in the same network on the same day. Every duplicate tells buyers the voice was planted. Rewrite the hub as prompts and talking points, ask each advocate to add their own experience, and make affiliation visible on their profiles. A handful of personal posts will build more credibility than synchronised volume.
How do we reach procurement when our community is all scientists?
Spend a week researching where procurement professionals in your target accounts learn: associations, newsletters, events and peer groups. Ask two friendly customers which sources their purchasing teams trust. Then pick one venue and find a credible person in your company, often from finance or operations, who can contribute something useful about the buying process. The aim is for procurement to hear a thoughtful voice from you before a scientist mentions your name.
Which voice is a life science tools company usually missing, and how do we earn one?
Often it is the independent customer who can describe day-to-day use. You cannot buy that credibility, so help someone earn it. Pick one core facility manager or power user who already answers peers' questions. Offer early access, a speaking slot at your user meeting or co-authorship on an application note, and credit them publicly. Leave their words alone, because their independence is the reason people listen.
How much governance is too much?
Run one test on every rule you have: does it shape the space or the speaker? Disclosure requirements, conduct standards and posting cadence protect credibility. Dictating what an independent customer says removes the reason anyone believes them. For employees, write a one-page guideline covering disclosure and topics to avoid, then let them speak in their own words. If you feel the need to approve every post, trust is already broken at the source.